The gas station guide nobody asked for
Looking back through several travel posts I realized that I discuss a lot of gas stations. Mostly food at gas stations. To be fair, we’ve moved way past the Stucky’s era of “a place to stop and get candy and kitschy souvenirs” and Howard Johnsons. I don’t really know if I’ve ever been to a Stucky’s, if I did I was really little and don’t remember. I have stayed at a Ho-Jo though….
Starting at the top of the alphabet: Buc-ee’s is in a class of its own – just by sheer volume. They’ve been in Texas since the 1980’s, but in 2018 they started expanding east – specifically along the Florida Spring Break routes. The food is crazy good – especially the brisket. Non brisket foods that I love are the fried chicken sandwich, Beaver Nuggets, fudge, cotton candy, and Overbites. I also like that you can get a cheese cups, fruit cups and cookie dough cups. I’m not a jerky person, but everyone seems to like all their jerky flavors. Things I don’t love – it is always crowded, you have to eat your food in your car and some are hard to get in/out of. How to navigate a Buc-ee’s – they are less crowded on weekdays and early morning/late night hours, do not get sucked into the clothing, souvenir or home goods area (unless you purposely went for that reason), and if there is an evacuation order in Florida – just keep driving. There are 2 Buc-ee’s in Florida and 3 in Georgia – they will be packed beyond capacity if people are fleeing Florida. The only Buc-ee’s I’ve been to are the newer massive ones along interstates that lead to sunny, sandy beaches, but some of the ones in Texas are just normal gas station size.
Normal size brings me to my next stop, Casey’s. Scattered throughout the Midwest in some very small town locations, Casey’s is best known for it’s pizza. I’ve only had their pizza once, and it was just a slice of sausage – they also have some specialty pizzas. It’s good pizza. Supposedly their breakfast sandwiches – and breakfast pizza are also good. What I like about Casey’s – when you’re in the middle of nowhere, you can find one, they have lots of snacks and drinks, and the pizza is yummy. Casey’s is also ranked #2 on the USA Today’s “Top 10 Gas Station Brands” list.
Pilot Flying J – I would skip it – I mean kind of. The original Flying J – 100% pass. Now they have merged with Pilot and they are not a bad option to stop at when travelling. Mostly because they have either a Cinnabon or Dunkin Donuts inside (or both!). Seriously, since Pilot took over, they are a lot cleaner and nicer. Also if you download their app and create an account you get discounts on gas, usually 10 cents/gallon. Keep in mind they are truck stops so the semi traffic can be hard to negotiate in a few cramped locations.
Gallahan’s Travel Plaza (now called JJ’s) – you won’t find this anywhere but Indiana. Specifically Peru, Indiana. And there is literally nothing remarkable about the food, it has a McDonalds and a Subway inside. But it’s an old friend when you have to drive US31 from Indy to South Bend… or Elkhart.. or Mishawaka. Which I did a lot in my first 3 years working for the state.
Another place I’ve only been to a few times is Huck’s. Which is weird because they are all located within a four hundred mile radius of my house. I’ve only ever stopped for gas or drinks, but I found out they have an INSANE food menu! Pizza, chicken, sandwiches. something called BIGG sauce and Godfathers pizza. Now that I know that, I will be on the lookout for one when I’m south.
I’ve never been, but I have it on good authority (from a native Wisconsinite/Badger) Kwik-Trip has the worlds best carrot cake. The secret is the icing which is actually cinnamon roll icing. Kwik-Trip makes not only all of its bakery items but 80% of all the items inside a Kwik-Trip are made, shipped and sold by their company. Even the milk they sell is bottled in-house and comes from farms within a 100 mile radius of their processing plant. Apparently the donuts, called Glazers, are also epic. They are primarily located in Wisconsin and Minnesota, so next time I’m north-north I’m going to stop and get some donuts and fresh milk. Kwik-Trip is ranked #1 on the USA Today’s “Top 10 Best Gas Stations Brand” list.
Coming in at #10 on USA Today’s list is Love’s. This is probably where we stop the most on road trips. Why? They also offer 10 cents/gallon discount with their app, they are always clean, they have a ton of Love’s brand snacks and they have roller food as well as fresh fruit. Some days you just need a Tornado from the roller grill. Not that we travel with our dogs, but Love’s is pet friendly with many locations having dog parks and some have dog washes as well. The best snack ever on a road trip is the Love’s Sweet & Salty Trail mix. Well…. at least until you get to Buc-ee’s and get Beaver Nuggets.
Rounding out the list (and the end of the alphabet) are Wawa and Wally’s. Let’s start with Wawa. I’m not sure what gas station first came up with made to order food, but Wawa has it perfected. The made to order sandwiches, wraps, pizzas – I could go on and on. My only note: For your biscuit sandwiches you need to be able to have bacon AND egg (not just pick one). But the best thing about Wawa is:
Iced Mocha Mint Coffee
They are so good I even got one the other day – when it was 26 degrees outside. Who gets iced coffee when it’s 26 degrees outside? If you know me and my complete disdain for cold weather…. you know it must be good!
Moving on to Wally’s. To be honest… the carving station food isn’t great. Which is disappointing. The popcorn is a tasty treat though – and they have cheddar, butter, caramel and Chicago style (cheddar & caramel mixed). Dave said the jerky is good too. And even though the BBQ sandwich isn’t much to write home about, I bought a bottle of Wally’s BBQ sauce and I really like it. Dave doesn’t. But I like more tomato-y, tangy, sweet BBQ sauce and Dave prefers a more hickory style BBQ sauce. “Meh” food aside – I would still stop here, just maybe not with the expectation to eat lunch or dinner. Why? Wally bear is adorable! Seriously though their merch is on point with “the great American road trip.” From the Wagoneer station wagon (you can hear “Holiday Road” buzzing in your head – can’t you?) to the Winnebago RV – all of the shirts, hats, stickers, pins, postcards reflect that summer vacation road trip. And I almost forgot they have ice cream too! Again, I can’t quantify ice cream for anyone, I love all ice cream. They also have slushies in a lot of flavors – in their “Sloosh” area.
An honorable mention should probably go out to RaceTrac – they have really good pizza, and they were the only station with gas in Ft. Myers during Hurricane Milton. Since I spend an inordinate amount of time in Florida I will tell you that I’m not a huge 7/11 fan. I know we have them in Indiana, but in Florida they are at every intersection. And nothing food related, but I love the Sinclair dinosaur. Sinclair doesn’t have many stations in Indiana, but a fun scavenger hunt item is to find the actual dinosaur statues – there are three located in Indiana. 🦕I’ve seen two of the three.
I have never been to Iowa 80 Truckstop – the “Worlds Largest Truckstop.” But it has a food court with Wendy’s, Pizza Hut, Taco Bell, DQ, Orange Julius, Caribou Coffee and Einstein Bros. Bagels. I’d go just for the Caribou Coffee and Einstein Bros. – but I have zero travel plans to go to Iowa. 😉
Finally… Ever since I saw it in the movie Forces of Nature I have always wanted to go to South of the Border. I came close once – but when you’re travelling to South Carolina traffic can sometimes mess up all your plans. One day I will make it there – and go to the top of the Sombrero Tower and eat at the Sombrero Room. I mean, South Carolina is one of my favorite places to visit!
What’s your go to gas station food?










