“In my life I was lucky to have a great loving mother and father.”
Donna was born at St. Mary Elizabeth Hospital, Louisville KY in 1942 to wonderful parents Dorothy “Dot” Harriett (Kepley) and Earl MacPherson Baughn. Being born during WWII, the hospital announcement of her birth looked like a War Bond. At the time, the family including her two-year-old brother, James Bryan Baughn (Jim), lived in Marengo Indiana. The house in Marengo was built by Earl’s father, James Brice McPherson Baughn, at the corner of Main St. and North Cherry St. Her father worked for Public Service Indiana and was a founding member of the volunteer fire department in Marengo, and he served as the Fire Chief.

She wrote a few memories from her early childhood, including how at age three she got her hand caught in the wringers of the washing machine. On wash day Dot had to go to the grocery store and left the kids with her dad, James Coral Kepley (“Pop”). Pop and the preacher that lived across the street were playing checkers upstairs when Donna decided to help her mom with the washing. Before Dot left, she had turned the washer off, released the wringers and shut the door to the washroom with a hook lock. Donna scooted a chair over to the door and unhooked the lock, turned the washing machine on and put the wringers together. She got a handkerchief stuck in the wringer but had seen her mom pull them out with her hand, so she tried to do the same. The problem was when she pulled the handkerchief the wringer pulled harder and her right hand went into the wringer. Her thumb got stuck which prevented her whole arm from going in. Luckily, the preacher who was there knew how to undo the wringers to free her hand. Pop called the grocery store to and asked them to send Dot home, Donna says she remembers the look on her mom’s face when she saw her hand. They took her to a hospital in New Albany, Indiana (today that trip is approximately 40 minutes). The most damage was done to her two middle fingers and the doctor in New Albany wanted to amputate them. Her dad refused to let them, and she was taken to Riley Hospital in Indianapolis (today that trip is approximately 1 hour and 45 minutes). Dot and Earl had to leave her at the hospital in the care of the nurses for several weeks before the operation, and then were not allowed to stay with her after the operation while she recovered for another several weeks. She had several surgeries over the years due to her hand injury, the last one was her freshman year in high school.
Another memory she had written from Marengo was when downtown caught on fire, they lived on a hill overlooking downtown and they could hear and see can’s popping in the air from their yard. In February 1950 her baby brother, John Mack Baughn was born. In 1951 when she was in the third grade the family moved to Hillside Avenue in Spencer Indiana. Earl had transferred to Spencer with his Public Service Indiana job as an opportunity to send the kids to a better school. The house in Marengo was torn down, possibly after an F3 tornado in 2004 had damaged 75% of the town. Currently, on the lot where their old house stood is the station for the Marengo-Liberty Township Volunteer Fire Department.
Dot and Earl built a house at 425 Lovers Lane in Spencer and later in life Donna enjoyed telling people she grew up on Lovers Lane. She wrote that when she returned home from a date she had to go straight to the house – no “parking” on Lovers Lane. She mentions that her dad also became the Fire Chief in Spencer. From some of the newspaper clippings that were in the folder with the life story she had started, we know she was one of five girls from the Spencer Intermediate Girl Scout Troop No. 3 that went to Camp Wapehani where they participated in nature study, campcraft and handicraft activities. Another clipping said that she was one of three girls who went to a baton twirling contest where she placed either second or third. The article was noticeably short and didn’t give a lot of details other than Mrs. Charles Sharp had taught the girls’ twirling lessons and accompanied them on the trip.

There were several handwritten notes that she looked to have added as afterthoughts, mostly from her high school days. She mentioned being a majorette with the band and roller skating. According to Jim they went roller skating at many rinks in and around Spencer. Donna even had her own roller skates which we found in a case in her house after she passed away. In high school Jim also DJ’d school dances and she wrote how the girls would dance and try and get the boys to dance. In 1959 she modeled for a travel brochure highlighting Sweet Owen County, she was pictured sitting at McCormick’s Creek. The photographer listed her as Earl Baughn’s daughter.

Donna got married when she was very young to a man named Glen Dyer and they lived in an apartment on Franklin Street in Spencer. They then moved to Indianapolis where they first lived on Shepherd St then Oliver Street. She went to Porter College where she got a certificate in Basic Key Punch. She wrote about her job as a cashier at an exclusive dress shop called Peck & Peck located on the circle in Indianapolis. Once when her store won an award the manager sent her to the Circle Tavern to pick up champagne even though she wasn’t 21. She was dressed in her best gray wool dress with a red scarf and red shoes and when she entered the tavern some of the servicemen in the tavern made her uncomfortable. When she got back the bartender called her manager and told him not to send her back. She remembered it as “quite an experience for a small-town girl.”
Porter College then sent her on an interview with L. Strauss and she started working there as the payroll clerk for the whole store. Later she started working for McCollum Typewriter and Adding Machines store which was ran by Helen and Ken Lukenbill. She enjoyed working for Helen and Ken and considered them her second parents. Their son Ken Jr was in law school and she would sometimes type his papers for him.
In 1973 Donna became a member of the Daughters of the American Revolution, Dot was also a member. The extensive paperwork to be admitted to the organization was also included in this box of photos, newspaper clippings and genealogy. She is a descendant of John Hurst a Lieutenant in Militia of Shenandoah County, Virginia – he took oath April 20, 1778. John Hurst had 12 children, the second John J. Hurst married Martha Manafee and they had a child, Martha Hurst. Martha Hurst married Rynard Kepley who is Donna’s Great Great Grandfather.
Donna divorced her first husband in 1979 and moved back to Spencer. She lived in a duplex on Franklin Street and started working for Helen Lukenbill’s brother Jim McCollum in Bloomington. She stated she “enjoyed working for them both” – referring to the Lukenbills and Mr. McCollum. Donna wrote about how she was immensely proud to purchase her own house in 1979. “Being a single woman, you could only have a two-bedroom home. In 1979 two-bedroom homes were usually about 20 years old, needed a lot of work and weren’t in a great neighborhood.” Earl would drink coffee with the territory FHA manager about once a week so he mentioned Donna’s situation and the gentleman said they could not discriminate against her. Donna fell in love with a three-bedroom home in Westbrook Downs addition in Bloomington on N. Ridgewood Dr. She was able to purchase the home and on the day of her closing both the gentleman from FHA and her dad were there to make sure she was treated right at the Bloomington office. Because of her story another girl she worked with was able to also purchase a three-bedroom home, originally told she could only purchase a two bedroom, but she mentioned Donna’s name and the FHA allowed the exception. “I lived in that house for 33 years.”
In a small handwritten note, she mentions that in 1980 she married the “love of my life, Harley McKittrick.” For an unknown reason, Donna didn’t write much about the 33 years she and Harley spent together and the life they had. But anyone who ever visited them knew they enjoyed travelling and their involvement with the Shriners. From the time I joined the family in 1997 we always celebrated Baughn family holidays at Donna and Harley’s. Sadly, her only notes regarding she and Harley’s life are as follows: “There is one thing they talk about the Golden Years – WRONG! It is the tarnished years. Harley and I had a great life together and the worst part was we were at the point where we were going to be able to do some travelling and he became sick. Losing Mother February 8, 2012 and Harley January 7, 2013 was rough.”
She has several notes about Dot’s death on February 8, 2012 which was also the day Dot’s mother Anna P Kepley died. Anna interestingly was born February 8, 1877 and died February 8, 1922 at the age of 45 but when Dot was only 22 months old. Dot was raised by her aunt Martha Christine “Byrd” (Kepley) Cusick whom she usually referred to as “Auntie.”
The box we found her autobiography in contained an abundance of family pictures showing how much she loved every member of her family. Pictures of her nieces and nephews growing up and even her great niece and nephew growing up. Pictures of her brothers and mom and dad and mementos of them growing up was like taking a trip back in time.

Donna scribbled several notes in the margins of her typed one-page (front and back) autobiography. I believe they were things she remembered from her childhood and growing up that changed significantly before she died. They are: Dr. came to our house, no man on moon, didn’t lock doors, no microwave, ball point pens, no TV only radio, sit in front of radio and listen to Lone Ranger “only 3 channels”, had to ring the operator to make a call and to find out where her friends were (I think she lists the operators name, and says she always knew where the friends were), take pictures on a roll of film then take it to the drug store to develop it and print it for us, everyone learned to drive with “shifting gears car,” no cell phone (she listed that like 3 separate places!) and first TV.
Donna Susan Baughn McKittrick had a unique life that deserved a little more than a one-page draft with notes in the margin that had some type of liquid spilled on it. I hope this is a little more descriptive.